The best way to avoid auto repair rip-offs is to be
prepared. Knowing how your vehicle works and
how to identify common car problems is a good
beginning. It is also important to know how to
select a good technician, the kinds of questions
to ask, and your consumer rights.
Repair Information
In Wisconsin, motor vehicle repairs are governed
by Wis. Adm. Code ch. ATCP 132. The law
includes businesses that install or repair
accessories, such as stereos, and covers shops
that rebuild parts.
Choosing a repair shop
Ask for recommendations from friends, family,
and other people you trust.
Look for an auto repair shop before you need
one to avoid being rushed into a last-minute
decision.
Shop around by telephone for the best deal
and compare warranty policies on repairs.
Contact DATCP’s Bureau of Consumer
Protection to see if there is a record of
complaints about a specific repair shop.
Look at online reviews for the company. Make
sure the shop will honor your vehicle’s
warranty.
Repair charges and service terms
Wisconsin car repair shops must get your
authorization for any repair and must offer you
an estimate, or firm price quote, if repairs will
cost $50 or more.
No unauthorized repairs are allowed. But if
you drop off your car before the shop opens
with a note to repair something and you do
not ask them to call you with an estimate
the shop can charge what it wants.
No unauthorized price increases are allowed.
If a shop provided an estimate or quote, they
need your permission to increase the price.
A shop may hold your vehicle until you pay for
authorized repairs. However, once you have
paid for authorized repairs, the shop cannot
keep your vehicle because you refused to
pay for unauthorized repairs.
When requesting additional authorization, the
shop must tell you both the cost for the
additional repairs and the new total cost of
the complete job. Make sure you leave a
telephone number where the shop can reach
you.
• If a shop accepts a prepayment of $250 or
more, the shop cannot start any repairs until
they provide an oral or written estimate of
the repair completion date and include that
estimate on the repair order. If the shop fails
to do this, the estimated completion date will
be the same date the motor vehicle or part is
delivered to the shop for repair.
The shop must return replaced parts to you if
you ask for them before repair begins.
Warranty parts or parts exchanged for
rebuilding need not be returned, but must be
made available to you for inspection.
When work is completed, the shop must
provide you with an invoice describing the
repairs, replaced parts (specifying if used or
rebuilt), and warranties for repairs and parts.
If you need expensive or complicated repairs,
or if you have questions about their
recommended repairs, consider getting a
second opinion.
Shops that do only diagnostic work and do
not sell parts or repairs may be able to give
you an objective opinion about which repairs
are necessary.
Double Damages – If the vehicle repair law
is violated, you may be able to start an
action in Small Claims Court. Wis. Stat. §
100.20(5) enables consumers to recover
twice the amount of any monetary damages,
court costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees.
After the work is done
The shop must provide you an invoice
describing the work done. The invoice
should list each repair, parts replaced and
the cost of each part, labor charges, the
odometer reading when you brought the
vehicle in, and the date the vehicle was
returned to you.
The shop must also return parts if you
requested them before the repairs began. If
the shop needs to return a part under a
warranty, the shop must allow you to inspect
the parts before your vehicle is returned.
Warranty & service contracts
WarrantiesThere is no “standard warranty”
on repairs. Make sure you understand what is
covered under your warranty and get it in
writing. Be aware that warranties may be
subject to limitations, including time, mileage,
deductibles, businesses authorized to perform
warranty work, or special procedures required
to obtain reimbursement.
Service ContractsMany vehicle dealers and
others sell optional service contracts issued by
vehicle manufacturers or independent
companies. Not all service contracts are the
same; prices vary and usually are negotiable.
To help decide whether to purchase a service
contract, consider:
The cost.
The repairs to be covered.
Whether coverage from the service contract
overlaps coverage provided by any other
warranty.
The deductible.
Where the repairs are to be performed.
Required procedures to file a claim, such as
prior authorization for specific repairs or
meeting required vehicle maintenance
schedules.
Whether repair costs are paid directly by the
company to the repair shop or whether you
will have to pay first and get reimbursed.
The reputation of the service contract
company. Contact DATCP’s Consumer
Protection Hotline to check for complaints
against a business: (800) 422-7128 or
DATCPHotline@wisconsin.gov.
Resolving a dispute
Document all transactions, as well as your
experiences, with dates, times, expenses,
and the names of people you dealt with.
Talk to the shop manager or owner first. If
that does not work, contact DATCP’s Bureau
of Consumer Protection. Another option is to
file a claim in small claims court. You do not
need an attorney to do this.
Repair Shop Prohibited Practices
(Wis. Adm. Code § ATCP 132.09)
Shops cannot do any of the following:
Knowingly underestimate the price of repairs
or the time required to complete the repairs.
Misrepresent any of the following:
o That certain repairs are necessary for
the safety or effective operation of a
vehicle.
o That a motor vehicle is in a dangerous
condition.
o That failure to repair the vehicle will be
harmful to the vehicle.
o That a repair has been made.
o The terms of a warranty or service
agreement.
Fail or refuse to return your vehicle if you
decline to pay for unauthorized repairs or
charges that exceed the estimate or firm
price quotation.
Intentionally alter a vehicle to create a
condition requiring repairs.
Make any repair or warranty advertisement
that is untrue, deceptive, or misleading.
Fail to honor any warranty or service
agreement to which the shop is a party.
Demand payment for unauthorized repairs, or
for repairs that have not been completed.
Charge, or threaten to charge, for preparing a
repair estimate or fixed price quote unless
the charge constitutes reasonable
compensation for preliminary diagnostic
work required to provide an accurate
estimate; and if the shop representative
discloses the charge, or the rate at which the
charge will be computed, prior to starting any
diagnostic work.
• Falsify or destroy any document or record
required to be produced or retained by law.
• Refuse to perform repairs unless you agree to
waive any right provided by ATCP 132.
For more information or to file a complaint,
visit our website or contact:
Wisconsin Department of Agriculture,
Trade and Consumer Protection
Bureau of Consumer Protection
2811 Agriculture Drive, PO Box 8911
Madison, WI 53718-8911
Email: DATCPHotline@wi.gov
Website: datcp.wi.gov
PHONE: (800) 422-7128 TTY: (608) 224-
5058
MV-RepairTips456 (rev 6/23)
Motor
Vehicle
Repair
Tips
Bureau of Consumer Protection